Among all my co-sisters, S is the only one from a wealthy family. My father-in-law looked up to her father who was a self-made man and had five daughters and no son. So when her father wanted his second son who was getting slightly out of hand as the resident son-in-law, I suppose my father-in-law was relieved. My husband's impression of S as a child is that of a girl who was very well aware of the economic positions of both the families but then her husband was a good looking guy in his younger days, has retained a very good sense of humour and has the best temper among six brothers so I guess that worked in his favour. They seem to have been a very happy couple all these years too.
But what she has never been happy about is the family she got through her husband and she's never made any bones about it. The circumstances of her marriage seem to have given her a strong sense of detachment but she retained the feeling of entitlement nevertheless. My in-laws' place provided enough opportunities for a critic; the muddy approach road was and to some extent is, a terrible mess most times, the house itself had nightmarish facilities, if at all, especially so for anybody who believed in least amount of privacy. To boot, the firewood kitchen would spew ample smoke and if it rained, the hall and the rest of the house would be like two islands. S visited the place on occasions and she says she spent the first few years sitting on the steps of the door opening to the alley with tears in her eyes; from smoke or otherwise. But I've wondered often that she visited so many times at all; may be it was because she had running feuds with her sisters and parents both and she wanted to show them that she had someplace else to go to.
When I got married in 2003, things hadn't really changed except for the construction of a toilet and a better-designed bathroom. S visited my in-laws' place whenever I did and for me, who was struggling to find my feet there, she was support, a comfort and a relief. She gave expression to many of my frustrations, which I could never do myself because I thought it wasn't appropriate. S never seemed to have any such qualms; I remember her in the old house with a perpetual frown on her face, a picture of oddity sitting on a chair fanning herself furiously with a newspaper roll and when tired, requesting some child to do it for her, criticizing the men for being stingy in not having a generator. She was a marvel to me, a refreshing one; I had never seen anybody who was so outspoken, least of all a lady, a daughter-in-law. I was proud of her, of her ability to pinpoint the reasons for the current state of affairs and that she wouldn't even spare my father-in-law, who was and still is the holy cow of the household. And she did it all as if there was an invisible protective layer around her; a shield of sheer contempt emanating from her which kept other people from counter-attacking her often-sharp-and-harsh comments. My mother-in-law would mutter some defenses, my third co-sister would silently sulk and my brothers-in-law would laugh and move on.
But over the years, as I gelled more with the family, the novelty began to wear off for me. I began to realise that her brutal assessment was not always right and that she rarely acknowledged merit in anyone or anything that the family did. Yet, people tried hard to please her and it seemed nothing was good enough until she approved of it. We moved to a new house, facilities improved, new co-sisters joined us but S remained the same. May be I developed a thick skin or I could just see that people were earnest about bringing about changes, may not be overnight but very much visible to someone who wanted to see it, S lost me somewhere along the way. It seemed as if she had become a compulsive critic and she was afraid that if she said a good word they would appropriate her for good and she couldn't allow that. Anyway, I started contradicting her when I could, respectfully but firmly. Then a lot of things happened in the family and now she's strictly not on talking terms with them, putting me in a quandary. I call her up once in a few months but it's not easy for me. But I do feel sorry for her at times.